I run a heavily home-brewed version of Swords & Wizardry. Many in my gaming group, as well as myself, enjoy the process of home-brewing, and even those who don't actively involve themselves enjoy at least some of the fruits of our home-brewing. As a result of over a year of home-brewing, we're starting to have a system that fits our group better than any game could when run "as-is," in much the same way that (I hear) tailored suits fit better than any store-bought, "as-is" suit ever does.
In fact, in much the same way that I think New School players are playing (rather than preparing for playing) when they work on their character builds, home-brewing, for at least some of us in the group, is an enjoyable activity in and of itself, not merely preparation for actual play sessions.
There is a downside to home-brewing, though it is, in my opinion, far outweighed by the benefits. This downside is decreased compatibility with just about everything else other people are doing. Probably the best example for my own game is the fact that, as far as I can tell, NOBODY except the publishers of Dungeonslayers and myself uses the metric system in Old School D&D. Distances are usually pretty easy to mess with: five foot squares are two meter squares and a mile is two kilometers- hardly exact, but good enough when exact conversions aren't needed at all. More fiddly is weight, especially since we use a kilogram-based encumbrance system. I generally can just say that two pounds is about a kilogram, but when goods are sold in lengths, weights and volumes, that requires conversion. I've received a refresher course in my middle school Home Ec classes just by having to figure out how to convert different Imperial volume measurements into liters.
The end result of all this non-compatibility that is most an inconvenience, though, is character sheets. With all the systems and rules we've bolted on- a small skill system, movement and encumbrance being done in metric, distinguishing race and class, and only slightly non-standard rules for hirelings and henchmen- plus the fact that no other game I know of uses a single save system like Swords and Wizardry does, it's little wonder that I've had to create a character sheet for us to use. It's nothing pretty, but it works and works well. On a lark, I'm posting a link to it here; it probably won't be terribly useful to anyone but it might be interesting, especially if you've wondered about the execution of some of the home-brewing I've discussed on this blog. Unfortunately, I can't figure out how to get my character sheet into a version I can post on this blog, but, thanks to Google Documents, you can find the PDF version here.
Showing posts with label Metric System. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Metric System. Show all posts
Thursday, January 5, 2012
Monday, July 11, 2011
Metric System for Old School D&D: Distance and Speed
Time to channel some of my Gamer ADD into actually making progress on one of my older series, in which I lay out a system to use the metric system in D&D. My reasons for doing this are multiple: my players' and my own convenience and ease, training people (especially students) to use the metric system, and how well kilograms work as a compromise in granularity between stones and pounds as a unit of weight for encumbrance.
Last time (quite a while ago), I covered weight and encumbrance; this time I'm going to cover distance and speed which, unless I'm forgetting anything, will mean that the only area left to cover after this post will be a catalog of items, including their weight in kilograms.
Wilderness distances are measured in kilometers (.621 miles). Six mile hexes can be converted into 12-kilometer hexes and the actual difference between 6 miles and 12 kilometers handwaved away. The distance from top to bottom is 12 kilometers, from corner to opposite corner is almost exactly 14 kilometers, the distance from the center of a hex to the midpoint of a side is exactly six kilometers and the distance from the center of a hex to a corner is almost exactly 7 kilometers.
The speed, in kilometers per day, of a character is calculated from the character's Base Movement Rate (discussed in the previous post on this topic). A character traveling at a "normal" pace will cover six time their BMR in kilometers in a day. This means that an unencumbered character (with BMR 4) will cover 24 kilometers in a day- almost 15 miles. If we go off the assumptions that a normal person will cover 12 miles a day at a "normal" pace, and that adventurers are in at least slightly better-than-average shape, this makes sense. It also means that an unencumbered party can cover about two hexes a day.
Characters can "forced march" and cover 12 times their BMR in kilometers a day, but their players must roll at or under their Constitution scores or they are fatigued at the end of the day. A fatigued character loses one hit point for each kilometer they travel at more than a leisurely "half" pace. Characters can recover from fatigue with a good night's sleep and a half-day's rest. An unencumbered character, then, would cover 48 kilometers- almost 30 miles- in a day if on a forced march. That's probably pretty generous, but, hey, this is D&D and I'm devising a simple system that works, not an exact simulation of overland travel.
During combat all distances are measured in meters. During outdoor combat, characters may move up to three times their BMR in meters in a combat round (one minute). During indoor combat, characters move up to their BMR in meters during a combat round.
Indoor distances are also measured in meters. A character moving at a careful pace, the only pace at which mapping is possible, may cover 10 times their BMR in meters during one turn. (A turn is ten rounds. A round is one minute, so a turn is ten minutes.) A character moving at a normal pace (perhaps in an already-mapped portion of a dungeon, or on the way out of a dungeon) may cover up to 20 times their BMR in meters during one turn. A character that is running may cover up to 40 times their BMR in meters during one turn.
An unencumbered character, then, would cover 40 meters in ten minutes at a careful pace, 80 meters in ten minutes at a normal pace and 160 meters in ten minutes while running. Keep in mind that this is all in an indoor- that is, dungeon- environment, so the running speed is for running through a poorly lit, irregularly leveled, cluttered and confusing environment, all with at least some dungeoneering gear, as opposed to running on a clear, open and level track with only runner's clothes to encumber. Perhaps "scrambling" would actually be a better term than "running."
What do you think? Is anything particularly out of whack?
Last time (quite a while ago), I covered weight and encumbrance; this time I'm going to cover distance and speed which, unless I'm forgetting anything, will mean that the only area left to cover after this post will be a catalog of items, including their weight in kilograms.
Wilderness distances are measured in kilometers (.621 miles). Six mile hexes can be converted into 12-kilometer hexes and the actual difference between 6 miles and 12 kilometers handwaved away. The distance from top to bottom is 12 kilometers, from corner to opposite corner is almost exactly 14 kilometers, the distance from the center of a hex to the midpoint of a side is exactly six kilometers and the distance from the center of a hex to a corner is almost exactly 7 kilometers.
The speed, in kilometers per day, of a character is calculated from the character's Base Movement Rate (discussed in the previous post on this topic). A character traveling at a "normal" pace will cover six time their BMR in kilometers in a day. This means that an unencumbered character (with BMR 4) will cover 24 kilometers in a day- almost 15 miles. If we go off the assumptions that a normal person will cover 12 miles a day at a "normal" pace, and that adventurers are in at least slightly better-than-average shape, this makes sense. It also means that an unencumbered party can cover about two hexes a day.
Characters can "forced march" and cover 12 times their BMR in kilometers a day, but their players must roll at or under their Constitution scores or they are fatigued at the end of the day. A fatigued character loses one hit point for each kilometer they travel at more than a leisurely "half" pace. Characters can recover from fatigue with a good night's sleep and a half-day's rest. An unencumbered character, then, would cover 48 kilometers- almost 30 miles- in a day if on a forced march. That's probably pretty generous, but, hey, this is D&D and I'm devising a simple system that works, not an exact simulation of overland travel.
During combat all distances are measured in meters. During outdoor combat, characters may move up to three times their BMR in meters in a combat round (one minute). During indoor combat, characters move up to their BMR in meters during a combat round.
Indoor distances are also measured in meters. A character moving at a careful pace, the only pace at which mapping is possible, may cover 10 times their BMR in meters during one turn. (A turn is ten rounds. A round is one minute, so a turn is ten minutes.) A character moving at a normal pace (perhaps in an already-mapped portion of a dungeon, or on the way out of a dungeon) may cover up to 20 times their BMR in meters during one turn. A character that is running may cover up to 40 times their BMR in meters during one turn.
An unencumbered character, then, would cover 40 meters in ten minutes at a careful pace, 80 meters in ten minutes at a normal pace and 160 meters in ten minutes while running. Keep in mind that this is all in an indoor- that is, dungeon- environment, so the running speed is for running through a poorly lit, irregularly leveled, cluttered and confusing environment, all with at least some dungeoneering gear, as opposed to running on a clear, open and level track with only runner's clothes to encumber. Perhaps "scrambling" would actually be a better term than "running."
What do you think? Is anything particularly out of whack?
Sunday, July 10, 2011
Roleplaying Units outside the US
So, working on a post for tomorrow, I now have a question for my readers that run games outside the US. How do you handle units in your roleplaying?
Do you use whatever system is assumed by whatever game you are playing or do you switch over to metric units? Do you just handwave more record keeping and encumbrance than you would prefer? What do your players think about units in your games?
Come to think of it, didn't TSR have a UK branch? Did they publish D&D with metric units? What about WOTC today- are there versions of 3.x and 4e published with metric units, I wonder? I would imagine that that would be downright necessary for non-English-language versions, right?
Do you use whatever system is assumed by whatever game you are playing or do you switch over to metric units? Do you just handwave more record keeping and encumbrance than you would prefer? What do your players think about units in your games?
Come to think of it, didn't TSR have a UK branch? Did they publish D&D with metric units? What about WOTC today- are there versions of 3.x and 4e published with metric units, I wonder? I would imagine that that would be downright necessary for non-English-language versions, right?
Saturday, February 19, 2011
Metric System for Old School D&D: Weight and Encumbrance
Call me biased (having grown up in Japan) or New School, or whatever, but I'm a big proponent of the Metric System. I'm also a big fan of how RPGs make math meaningful for kids and want to sponsor an RPG club when I'm a teacher. I think the US will, at some point in my lifetime, switch over to the Metric System, so I figure I should have a good, solid, playtested way to use the Metric System in the games I'm going to teach them. I, and my similarly biased (having also grown up in Japan) roommate from college days, have been working on how to do this, off and on, for maybe six months now. I'm going to start posting bits and pieces of it here, as that was one of the reasons I started this blog in the first place.
I figure we'll start with the encumbrance system.
The base unit for determining encumbrance is the kilogram (1000 grams). Some items will weight less than a kilogram, but nothing will weigh less than .1 kg (one hectogram). Creating a long, very complete item list with weights and prices is probably going to be what takes up the most of the time we put into this system.
We've started that process, but have certainly not finished it.
The encumbrance system is based around the idea of a Base Movement Rate, or BMR. Each character, based on encumbrance, is assigned a BMR of between 1 and 4 (monsters, exotic or magically aided characters might have a higher BMR) which can then be multiplied to determine how far a character can move in a certain amount of time in certain situations. I stole the BMR from Swords and Wizardry and divided it by three, since it was in feet and we're using meters for this system.
To determine what a character's BMR is, tally up the weight of what your character is carrying. Kilograms, by the way, hit a midpoint of granularity between the currently fashionable stones and the old-fashioned pounds. I actually tried using stones, but the player who is working on this with me revolted over them being too big, as far as units go, hence us working on this system to replace it.
Once you've determined the number of kilograms your character is carrying, compare that to your character's strength score. Consult the following:
Equal to or less than STR Score: 4
Thoughts?
I figure we'll start with the encumbrance system.
The base unit for determining encumbrance is the kilogram (1000 grams). Some items will weight less than a kilogram, but nothing will weigh less than .1 kg (one hectogram). Creating a long, very complete item list with weights and prices is probably going to be what takes up the most of the time we put into this system.
We've started that process, but have certainly not finished it.
The encumbrance system is based around the idea of a Base Movement Rate, or BMR. Each character, based on encumbrance, is assigned a BMR of between 1 and 4 (monsters, exotic or magically aided characters might have a higher BMR) which can then be multiplied to determine how far a character can move in a certain amount of time in certain situations. I stole the BMR from Swords and Wizardry and divided it by three, since it was in feet and we're using meters for this system.
To determine what a character's BMR is, tally up the weight of what your character is carrying. Kilograms, by the way, hit a midpoint of granularity between the currently fashionable stones and the old-fashioned pounds. I actually tried using stones, but the player who is working on this with me revolted over them being too big, as far as units go, hence us working on this system to replace it.
Once you've determined the number of kilograms your character is carrying, compare that to your character's strength score. Consult the following:
Equal to or less than STR Score: 4
Twice STR score or less: 3
Three times STR score or less: 2
4 times STR score or less: 1
No character can carry more than 4 times his/her STR score in kilograms.
It turns out that this makes for a simple, elegant and reasonably realistic system. A kilogram is about 2.2 pounds, so an average strength character (STR 10) can carry about 22 pounds without being encumbered and can carry no more than around 88 pounds. A character with STR 18 can carry almost 40 pounds (39.6, to be exact) without being encumbered and can carry up to 158.4 pounds.No character can carry more than 4 times his/her STR score in kilograms.
Thoughts?
Labels:
Metric System,
RPGs in School
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)